Login Here






Lost Password?
No account yet? Register
Boyfriend lies to me about contact with his ex
My boyfriend and I have been together for over a year and we live together. He claims that his ex-girlfriend is one of his best friends.

I have told him that I don’t know how two people that have been intimate can really remain ONLY friends. He says that there are none of those kinds of feelings there.

Recently he had to go away for work and I busted him for going to see her. He hid the fact that he went there from me. And even after I confronted him about this he continued to lie to me and tell me that I was crazy and that he never went to see her.

I couldn’t get this out of my head. Even though he had told me that he didn’t, I knew in my gut that he did. So I confronted him again and this time he came clean about it. He felt awful and told me he was sorry and that he would never lie to me again. He told me he lied about it because I have a jealousy towards this person and that I would not understand why he wanted to go and see her.

SO basically he told me that he lied to me and hid it from me because of my jealousy. I do not agree with their friendship and I cannot get the fact of them ever being intimate out of my head.

Is this unreasonable for me to feel this way or is my jealousy just getting the better of me? I feel like he chose to hurt me over seeing her... leaving me to feel less important then her.

Is this wrong?

Response:

This is a very difficult situation because you and your boyfriend do not understand each other with respect to an important issue. Your boyfriend has told you that his ex-girlfriend is one of his best friends. At the same time, you have told him that it isn’t possible to just be friends with an ex-lover.

To begin with, many people are friendly with an ex and there are a lot of benefits of doing so (see, talking to an ex). It may help to keep in mind that when it comes to love and romance, not everyone holds the same beliefs (see, love styles). So, it is possible for people to just be friends with someone who they have dated in the past, although this can be difficult for everyone to understand. In fact, after dating long enough, most couples, if they are lucky, end up as little more than friends, as passion starts to fade within a relationship.

But with that said, some people also maintain romantic ideas about an ex. For some people, letting go of their feelings for an ex can be difficult to do.

In your situation, your boyfriend has told you that he is just friends with his ex-girlfriend. But, then he lied to you about seeing her.

This is one of the most common things that couples lie about – contact with someone else (see, what lovers lie about).

And there are typically two reasons why people lie about such contact. People lie about this type of contact because it is inappropriate – it is sexual or romantic in nature. Or people lie about such contact because their partner disapproves of such behavior (see, partner’s disapproval).

Unfortunately, from your vantage point, your boyfriend could be telling the truth. Maybe he is only friends with his ex and he lied to you to avoid having to deal with your jealous response (see, overcoming jealousy). Or your boyfriend could still have feelings for his ex. If that is the case, his behavior would be very similar to what he’s done.

So, how should you respond?

You could try taking your boyfriend at his word. It is possible they are only friends and that he lied to you to avoid starting an argument. Ideally, it would have been best to take your boyfriend at his word early on, and then monitor how he reacts around his ex-girlfriend for signs of attraction. But, it is too late to do that now. Your boyfriend will be monitoring his own behavior too closely now to let his true feelings show.

Or you may also want to consider ending the relationship. If your boyfriend is close to his ex, and you cannot understand that, your difference of opinion will likely cause many other problems in your relationship. If you ask your boyfriend to end an important friendship to demonstrate his love for you, doing so often leads to high levels of resentment and anger (and perhaps hidden contact with her). And in the worst case – if he still loves her - forcing him to end the relationship will not change his feelings for her.

If you can find a way to trust that the two of them are only friends, that may be your best option for solving this problem.
Comments (10)add
im in the Same Situation
written by Kaitlin , January 24, 2007
I'm in almost the exact same situation. I'm 2 months pregnant with my boyfriend who I just found out that this past Saturday night he was actually with his ex girlfriend at a party and also at a local bar. Then I was told he left a voicemail on her phone telling her that he still cares a lot about her and he'd really want to work things out with her. He totally denies it and twisted the story completely around. I have no clue what to do. To either believe him and stay or just walk away.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
My ex
written by Rachy , January 27, 2007
I want to remain friends with my ex as we were close and I do not have any feelings for him other than as friends. I love my boyfriend, but he does not agree with me being friends with my ex. But to be honest, I would not like it if he was friends with his ex so you should consider your partners feelings. If you love your partner enough you would give up an ex as a friend. Kaitlin, I think you should stay with your boyfriend for the moment if you feel vulnerable. I have actually let my bf walk all over me while I've been pregnant but I need the emotional and financial help from him. I believe he is starting to change. He was scared at first. I don't think now is the right time to leave though unless you really think you should.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
...
written by kaitlin* , January 27, 2007
I just want to say that I am in the exact position. That I found out my boyfriend has been in contact with his ex for about a year, on and off, of our relationship. I found text messages. When I confronted him he lied, but I called his ex and then he confronted it. I found in my position that he was just lying to me to not cause a huge dilemma, but in that case he was still lying. He did end the friendship to demonstrate his love for me and to be faithful about when she calls him.
It is a very hard situation to deal with, but I figure if men are going to cheat they will do it regardless, and we will always find out, there is nothing you can do to stop them. You may go searching for something and realize there isn't anything hidden or you might find something and have to end it. But I think if you truly love someone, you can overcome anything.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Men are dogs
written by dumbone , January 29, 2007
My boyfriend still remains in contact with numerous exes and he knows it upsets me... they leave seductive text messages and he goes out to visit them in the middle of the night and he tells me "nothing is going on..." SURE!!!! I'm just the idiot he lives with and has a child with and one day I'll get a backbone and kick him to the curb. I don't need to catch him in bed with any of them to know that he's cheating on me... and I'm living in a miserable home because I'm not intimate with him anymore... I love him dearly, but I can't get over the fact that he remains in contact and still visits his exes.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
...
written by Bent , January 31, 2007
My ex girlfriend was still in love with her ex husband and behind my back, she continued to see him and sleep with him. It is very hard and deceitful, when you are in love with someone, who has not closed the doors to the past. An ex is and ex, doesn't matter what. The reason they are not together anymore, was because it didn't work. Some people just can't let go, but should not use another person, to move forward, when they have not closed doors to the past. I was deeply in love with my g/f and it hurt deeply, when I found out that she was playing both sides of the fence, he didn't know about me and I didn't know about him. And when it all came to the surface, it was a very hard blow.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Humpty Dumpty
written by Scoot , March 01, 2007
I just found out that he made arrangements to have aromatic dinner with his ex, while away on a supposed trip to spend his birthday with his family.
Not only did he have dinner plans but a hotel reservation too. I found out about it before the big night and busted him. He canceled all plans and seems sorry enough and I believe him. How am I supposed to get over this betrayal. I trusted this man with every fiber of my being. It took me a long time to even get there because of a previous relationship and the damage that was done, but here I am again and I just don't know where to go or what to do and feel so utterly alone.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
...
written by choosing to be blind , October 13, 2007
I have confronted my boyfriend about chatting with his ex online. He told me that they are just friends and can see nothing wrong with it. I read an IM conversation between them and they were obviously flirting. It made me sick. We are living together and I don't know what to do. I don't know if he's talked to her since I confronted him but I assume he has. I feel for all of you going through the same thing. It is so hard when you love the person and want to see the good in them. In my heart I know it'll end badly but I guess I'm just trying to buy my time with him. Pathetic isn't it?
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
...
written by Hurt , November 19, 2007
I can't believe the stuff I have read. Well I can, I just don't want to accept that it's fact for so many of us! My current fiance has contact with 3 of his ex gf's (that I know of). We've talked about it and he says to me: We are just friends. I love you and I want to be with you. Blah Blah Blah... uh huh I'm thinking. I have met the one and I know they are just friends, but the other 2... yeah I don't know. If I'm the one you want... why are you talking to not 1 but 3 of your ex's? And regularly. I know his information to his accounts so he feels I should be secure that he isn't hiding anything from me, because I can look whenever I want (he says) Ok, so my gut tells me he's lieing about talking to this one person. So I discovered (duh thru info I have) that he has talked to her when he said he would tell if he did again. Because she called one night while he was at my house and she freaked. So of course I was like why...y ou are just friends right? Anyway he said he would tell me if she called him again. Well the proof I have he called the very next morning at work! And now has lied to me about it, I've asked him twice and he denies it. What do I do? We are engaged to be married for God's sake! It's no wonder this world is so messed up and divorce is rampant! I love him...but right now I'm so fuming I just want to say screw it and walk. Any advice or suggestions? Thanks!
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
...
written by Ava , January 09, 2008
When a boy is lying to you about contact with his ex or telling you that his contact with her is a lot less often than it actually it is, it is time to MOVE ON. If he is lying there is a reason for it and you deserve someone better. I wish I would take my own advice.........
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
...
written by Been There, Did That , January 09, 2008
Dear Hurt,
Don't do it. Don't get married to a guy who doesn't feel incredibly lucky to be with you! There are guys out there who will love to treat you better, who will never lie to you.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Write comment

busy
 

Other Options:

  • View all tags as tag cloud (specific issues)
  • View all questions listed by topic (broader focus)

I have my own question to ask

Truth About Deception - back to our homepage.